Topline Summary:

Our elected Bargaining Committee met with the JHU admin for the 18th time on Tuesday. We were joined by a postdoc observer, and if you’re interested in being an observer at future bargaining sessions to hear what the JHU admin have to say, you can sign up here. We passed the admin four counter-proposals (Grievance and Arbitration Procedure, Discipline and Discharge, Public Safety, and New Employee Orientation), and in return, they passed us only one counter (International Employee Rights). After some questions and some back and forth, the session ended early. While we continue to push for strong rights and protections in our counters, the admin heavily edited the International Employee Rights article so they can easily cooperate with federal immigration officials with minimal legal requirements, highlighting where their priorities are at this moment. Despite this counter being disappointing, the session was productive overall, and we are drawing closer to agreements on many of the remaining noneconomic articles.

Our Counter-Proposals:

We began the session by presenting the JHU admin with our four counter-proposals and talking through our rationale. The admin engaged by asking a few questions, and we found it to be a productive exchange.

  • Grievance and Arbitration Procedure: We have held many of our positions in this article, but we’ve made some adjustments and reasonable compromises. We maintained that the JHU admin cannot file grievances against the Union, citing that they have previously confirmed they have other recourse through which they can seek to resolve issues and would be unlikely to ever use the grievance procedure. We adjusted our proposed grievance procedure so that it escalates to the Provost or Head of Labor Relations, without extending the timeline to reach arbitration with a neutral arbitrator. We continued to push for an extended deadline to file grievances for cases of sexual harassment or assault. We established fair expectations for both sides to bring up relevant issues and evidence before arbitration, and we maintained that we do not think it is necessary or appropriate restrict what remedies an arbitrator may reward. The admin asked a few clarifying questions, but offered no other response.

  • Discipline and Discharge: Working with the last counter-proposal from the JHU admin, we made some changes to address their concerns but held our stance on several matters. We restructured the first section of this article to address redundancies that the JHU admin disliked. We maintained that our contract explicitly state that the just cause standard applies to unjust termination for performance, as we have heard from postdocs that termination for poor performance with no record of said poor performance is an ongoing issue at Hopkins. We re-asserted that investigatory suspensions should be paid, and we specifically cited and read the current policy for postdocs that mandates we continue receiving pay and benefits during an investigatory suspension. We added language to clarify that interim measures must follow applicable law and standards, as they are dictated by JHU. At a previous session, the admin expressed concern that the outcome of an investigation is uncertain during the investigation, and they would therefore be unable to inform international postdocs if it may result in termination. In response, we proposed that international postdocs be informed before the investigation if termination is the proportional disciplinary action for the accused action. Again, the admin asked a few clarifying questions, but did not otherwise respond.

  • Public Safety: Both sides have made concessions on this article, and we continued to push hard for our rights while making reasonable compromises. We re-asserted that we will not be surveilled due to our status as union members, which is a right afforded to us by U.S. Labor Law, but we feel strongly that this is important to codify in our contract given the uncertain political climate. We accepted minor changes the JHU admin made to language that stipulates JHU will rely on discipline procedures rather than law enforcement for noncriminal conduct. However, we added back in our section on freedom of expression, which seeks to codify our right to peacefully protest on campus. We also reincorporated language that requires JHU to notify the union of changes to the JHPD, which they already have a duty to publicly announce to the community. We hope to continue to move closer to agreement when we receive the admin’s next counter on this article.

  • New Employee Orientation: We accepted many of the changes the JHU admin proposed in their last counter, including striking some of the detailed requirements for orientation. We moved on the timeline to implement new orientation requirements to within four months of contract ratification (vs the admin’s proposal of twelve months). We modified the language slightly to clarify that our union must be permitted to include content for orientation, and we stipulated that neither party may disparage the other (vs the admin’s proposal stating that only our union cannot disparage JHU). Finally, we accepted striking of some specific details around union representation at orientations. As the admin works on their counter on this article, we hope they give our positions the same reasonable consideration we’ve given theirs.

Our Questions:

We then asked the JHU admin questions about their latest counters on Intellectual Property and Workload. In explaining their most recent Intellectual Property counter-proposal, the JHU admin claimed that we are not eligible to be PIs on grants, but there are some grants that postdocs qualify for as a PI. In fact, one of our bargaining committee members is currently going through the process to be designated as a PI for a grant. The admin pushed back on language that we “will be” allowed to apply for grants as a PI if eligible, insisting on instead using the permissive “may be” so that University policy can restrict what grants we can apply for. When we pressed for justification, the admin said faculty may be competing with us for grants, and our ability to apply for eligible grants should be at the University’s discretion. We then asked about their concern with making us PIs on grants that we write, and they explained that writing a grant does not necessarily mean we should take on the responsibilities of a PI. We explained that we want to ensure we get credit for our work and are not subject to the whims of a supervisor, and the role of Co-Investigator was discussed as an alternative to PI.

In response to their rejection of our most recent Workload counter-proposal, we asked the JHU admin why they struck language that we are FLSA-exempt (non-hourly) employees, to which they explained that it would seem like we were bargaining over our status set by U.S. regulators. We responded that we need to be clear of what our status is as employees, because prior to unionizing we were sometimes considered students, staff, or “trainees,” so we maintain that clarifying this information in our contract is necessary. We are taking their responses into consideration as we draft our counters on these articles.

JHU Admin’s Counter-Proposal:

After we presented our counters and questions, the JHU admin passed us one counter on International Employee Rights.

  • International Employee Rights: The JHU admin struck most of our language and removed many of the rights and protections we are pushing for for our international members, who make up more than 70% of our union. The JHU admin adjusted requirements for providing information to the Department of Homeland Security (DHS) from a felony investigation to any investigation, lowering the bar for releasing information about us to DHS. Concerningly, they struck the sentence “Employees will not be held by University campus security on the basis of immigration status alone,” which puts our international members at risk of subsequent unjust federal detention. They struck our section that stipulated if we cannot work due to immigration-related reasons then we are placed on unpaid leave, and they replaced it with a link to their visa-related LOA policy, which fires an employee after 60 days. Similarly, they removed requirements to temporarily hold positions open if we cannot work due to immigration status. The admin struck most of our section on OIS’s responsibilities, leaving only a vague requirement to advise and maintain a website. They also removed most of our language for tax assistance and our entire section on ESL resources, both of which are offered for our graduate workers. When pressed, the admin said that we do not warrant services that already exist for graduate worker colleagues. We are working on our counter for this article, and we will continue to fight for strong protections for our many international members.

How can YOU help win a great first contract?

While we made some progress at this session, we still have issues left to resolve before we can get to bargaining over our economic conditions like pay, benefits, and childcare. Below are two ways that you can play an important role in conveying to the JHU admin that we want a contract that addresses our needs, priorities, and concerns now!

  • Sign our Open Letter: Nearly a majority of postdocs have signed our open letter calling on the JHU admin to resolve our remaining non-economic issues with real improvements put together from all of our collective input. If you have not already, read and add your name to the open letter today by clicking the link to show the JHU admin that we stand together on these issues!

  • Sign up to be an observer for a future bargaining session: Our next bargaining session is next Friday, November 13th from 8:00am-11:00pm on the East Baltimore School of Medicine (SOM) Campus in the Miller Research Building (MRB), Room #G01. The more of us who attend these sessions, the more the JHU admin understands how committed we all are to winning a great contract. Fill out this form to let us know that you can make it so someone from our team can reach out and coordinate plans for attending our next session.

As always, please reach out to us at this email or individually to any of our Bargaining Committee members listed below if you have any questions or thoughts about our bargaining process. You can also follow along with all current proposals and bargaining updates using our Bargaining Tracker linked here.

In solidarity, 

Andrew Chelius, Health, Behavior, and Society

Austin Ramsey, Cell Biology

Ben Seicol, Otolaryngology/ Head & Neck Surgery

Cat LaCourse, Pediatrics

Jaime Eugenin von Bernhardi, Neuroscience

Saakshi Dulani, Physics & Astronomy, Philosophy

Tianyu Cao, Pathology

PRO-UAW Bargaining Committee